3D printing has emerged as a popular option for saddle upgrades in cycling, offering customizable solutions to enhance rider comfort. Among the notable contenders in the market are Posedla’s Joyseat Pro 3.0 and Selle Italia’s SLR 3D, both priced around £400.
Posedla Joyseat Pro 3.0
Posedla’s approach to saddle design is unique; customers receive a "Smiling Butt Kit," which includes a gridded foam core for taking an impression. After completing a detailed survey that covers riding habits and personal measurements, Posedla crafts a personalized saddle based on this data. The result is a custom-made 3D-printed saddle with varying touch points, tailored to the user’s specific preferences.
Selle Italia SLR 3D
In contrast, the Selle Italia SLR 3D saddle is selected using the idmatch system, which measures pelvic dimensions to determine the appropriate saddle shape. This off-the-shelf model is designed with a carbon fiber shell and features a geometric padding pattern that varies in density and shape, providing support and comfort during rides.
Testing Methodology
Both saddles underwent an extensive testing process over eight months in different weather conditions. They were evaluated on rides of varying distances and paces, ensuring comprehensive assessment of comfort and performance. Each saddle was fitted based on individual fitting data to maximize comfort during long rides on different bikes.
Performance Comparison
The weight of the Selle Italia SLR 3D is notably lighter at 146.6g compared to the 163g Joyseat. However, the Posedla offers a bespoke comfort that is unmatched, with no need for adjustments once fitted. Both saddles showcased excellent comfort characteristics, though they differed in design and materials.
Conclusion
Ultimately, while both products represent excellent choices, the custom option from Posedla stands out for those seeking optimal comfort tailored specifically to their anatomy and riding style, despite its slightly longer lead time. Conversely, the Selle Italia offers a premium finish and aesthetic appeal, making it a strong contender in the off-the-shelf market. If comfort is your primary goal, the Posedla Joyseat Pro 3.0 may be the better choice for avid riders.
For further reading: